What is the difference between synchronized and lock in Java?

Tim 164 Published: 11/25/2024

What is the difference between synchronized and lock in Java?

In Java, synchronized and lock are two different mechanisms used to achieve thread synchronization, which ensures that multiple threads access shared resources concurrently without conflicts or data corruption.

Synchronized

The synchronized keyword is a low-level locking mechanism in Java that allows only one thread to execute a block of code at a time. When a thread enters a synchronized block, it acquires the lock associated with the object on which the method is declared. This lock is known as the intrinsic lock or monitor lock.

Here are the key characteristics of synchronized:

Method-level locking: You can apply synchronized to a specific method in your class. Intrusive locking: The synchronized keyword uses Java's built-in locking mechanism, which is implemented at the JVM level. Exclusive access: When one thread has acquired the lock, no other thread can enter the same synchronized block until the first thread releases the lock.

Lock

The lock mechanism in Java is a more explicit and flexible way to manage locks compared to synchronized. A ReentrantLock (a specific type of Lock) provides fine-grained control over locking and unlocking, allowing for more complex concurrency scenarios.

Here are the key characteristics of lock:

Class-level locking: You can create a ReentrantLock instance at the class level and use it to synchronize access to shared resources. Non-intrusive locking: The Lock interface is implemented explicitly by developers, providing more control over lock management. Multiple locks allowed: Multiple threads can acquire separate locks on different objects without conflicts.

Key differences

Level of abstraction: Synchronized provides a higher level of abstraction, while lock requires more explicit implementation. Lock scope: Synchronized applies to the entire method or block, whereas lock allows for finer-grained control over locking and unlocking. Concurrency scenarios: Synchronized is suitable for simple concurrency scenarios, while lock is better suited for more complex scenarios involving multiple locks, timeouts, and retries.

In summary:

Use synchronized when you need to ensure exclusive access to a shared resource at the method level, and the locking requirements are relatively straightforward. Choose Lock (or specifically ReentrantLock) when you require more control over lock management, fine-grained concurrency, or complex locking scenarios.

In practice, synchronized is often used for simple synchronization needs, while lock is typically employed in more advanced concurrency scenarios or when custom locking logic is required.

What is the difference between synchronized and lock in Java?

I'd be happy to help!

In Java, synchronization mechanisms are crucial for ensuring that multiple threads can safely access shared resources while maintaining data integrity. Two fundamental concepts used to achieve thread-safe programming are synchronized and lock. Understanding the differences between these two will enable you to write more effective and efficient multithreaded programs.

Synchronized

The synchronized keyword is used to ensure that only one thread can execute a block of code at a time. It is often used with methods, blocks of code, or classes to achieve mutual exclusion, which ensures that only one thread can access a shared resource simultaneously. When a thread tries to enter a synchronized block, it will be blocked until the current executing thread exits the block.

Here are some key characteristics of synchronized:

A synchronized block can only be executed by one thread at a time. All threads trying to enter the block will be blocked until the block is released. The lock is acquired automatically when entering the block, and released when exiting. Synchronized blocks support reentrant locking, allowing multiple nested locks.

Example:

public class Counter {

private int count = 0;

public synchronized void increment() {

count++;

}

public synchronized int getCount() {

return count;

}

}

In this example, the increment and getCount methods are synchronized, ensuring that only one thread can modify the counter's state at a time.

Lock

Java 5 introduced the java.util.concurrent.locks package, which provides more fine-grained control over thread synchronization. The ReentrantLock class allows you to create your own locks and apply custom locking strategies.

Here are some key characteristics of lock:

Locks can be acquired and released manually using methods like lock() and unlock(). You can implement custom lock behavior, such as timeouts or reentrancy. Locks support fairness, allowing you to prioritize thread execution. Multiple locks can be used simultaneously to manage different resources.

Example:

import java.util.concurrent.locks.ReentrantLock;

public class Counter {

private int count = 0;

private final ReentrantLock lock = new ReentrantLock();

public void increment() {

lock.lock();

try {

count++;

} finally {

lock.unlock();

}

}

public int getCount() {

lock.lock();

try {

return count;

} finally {

lock.unlock();

}

}

}

In this example, the ReentrantLock is used to manually acquire and release the lock when incrementing or retrieving the counter's state.

Key differences

To summarize:

synchronized is a keyword that automatically acquires and releases a lock when entering or exiting a block of code. lock is a more flexible approach that allows you to create your own custom locks and apply manual locking strategies. Synchronized blocks are ideal for simple, straightforward synchronization needs, while locks provide more control over thread interaction.

When deciding between synchronized and lock, consider the complexity and specific requirements of your multithreaded program. If you need fine-grained control or custom locking behavior, use locks; if you require automatic locking and mutual exclusion, choose synchronized.